I am dating a man who is Wiccan…we are having a very serious disagreement about a spider! I respect his Wiccan views and beliefs…but I cannot understand his logic regarding this topic. I am terrified of spiders…it is irrational and logically I know its silly. However, I cannot control that fear and it truly causes me serious distress. He has a very large spider living above his front door. Initially he wanted to bring it inside, but has agreed not to now. I asked him to relocate the spider because he does not believe in killing them. His response was no…it would cause the spider harm…and he believes in the first do no harm principle. Its his belief relocating the spider will directly cause it harm. Isn’t leaving the spider there causing me harm? It causes me to have heart palpitations, extreme anxiety, and I cry! Again, I know my fear is unsubstantiated, but it is real! I feel he is completely disregarding my feelings and well being by not relocating it…but all he says is do no harm is in his blood and who he is! Any advice?
I’ll start with straight and to the point. If your boyfriend cares more about potential harm to a spider, than he does about the woman he supposedly loves, then you need to RUN (not walk) to the nearest exit. Dump him.
Regardless of the actual meaning of the Rede itself (which I’ll get to in a moment), there are plenty of ways to humanely move a spider. There is absolutely zero reason for him to put that spider’s well-being above your own – A) because it can be moved without harming it and B) because even if it would cause harm… your life (and physical/mental health) should be a priority to him. If it’s not, then there is something seriously wrong. If he is not willing to put you first in these sorts of situations, he’s not worth your time or energy.
As to “do no harm” – at no point (ever), does the Wiccan Rede prohibit one from causing harm, and in fact, it is literally impossible to go through life without causing harm to someone or something. The Rede, which in full states ‘An it harm none, do what ye will, simply tells us that if it doesn’t cause harm, we can do whatever we want. But nowhere in that statement does it say if it causes harm, don’t do it. The point of it all, is for one to carefully consider their actions before taking them, and to be willing to accept the potential consequences of such actions – for good or bad. In the end however, if one feels that a harmful action is justified, and is willing to accept the consequences, then there is nothing preventing them from taking the action. For more information on the history and meaning of the Wiccan Rede, I suggest reading The Wiccan Rede: A Historical Journey.
It’s unfortunate that there are books and websites which offer misinformation regarding the Rede, which in turn cause people to end up believing that it is a literal prohibition against causing harm. But again as I mentioned to start, if your boyfriend is unwilling (or unable) to see that the harm he is causing to you is more detrimental than the harm moving the spider would cause, then he’s really not someone that you need in your life. It may sound harsh, but this is just a spider (and very easily remedied in a way that could make you both happy, which he is refusing to even consider)… what happens when it’s something more important?